Need a topper for new Serta Innerspring
Aug 21, 2012 7:45 PM
Joined: Aug 21, 2012
Points: 5
My new Serta isn't anything like the old one that lasted 8 years.  I can squish this one together with my hands and thought, at first, I had received a foam mattress by mistake.  It's hard to believe it has the advertised 700 plus coils.  It was one of the mid-range models, (Vanessa II cushion firm at Sears) with a 10 yr warranty so I thought I was getting something substantial.  I can't use the warranty since it's not defective.  I got it 60% off with free shipping and couldn't do better with an exchange.

After a week, buyer's remorse is hitting me hard.  I was expecting the support and refreshing coolness and springiness of the previous serta but this is like crawling onto a board with padding.  Have all the mattress companies gone foam crazy?  I think this model has pocket coils but they must be buried in foam. If it doesn't offer much in the way of comfort or support, can I at least count on it lasting several years? - I want to get my misery's worth.

Perhaps a higher-end topper will make this bed comfortable.  I already have a 2" topper with fitted cover I can use but don't like the heat issues.  Does a high density latex or cool gel topper sound like a good idea?  I used to buy high-density foam, throw a sheet over it and call it my bed when I was younger.  Now I'm starting to think I just need to get the raw materials and make a simple bed of my own.

Any ideas about toppers would be welcome.  Geez, I didn't even know what a topper was until I started shopping for a mattress this year.  It sounds to me like mattresses have gone downhill in quality and they dreamed up pillowtops and toppers to cover a multitude of sins. 

Re: Need a topper for new Serta Innerspring
Reply #8 Aug 31, 2012 11:21 AM
Joined: Aug 21, 2012
Points: 5
Follow-Up:  Sears sent a delivery team to pick up the mattress and gave me a full refund.  I thought I was stuck with the Serta beast but Sears made a return effortless.  No restocking or pick-up fee - in fact, I didn't even lose the shipping on the refund.  Very pleased with Sears and how easy they made it for me.

I've narrowed my search for a new mattress down to Saatva or Ezsleep Latex.  Since I don't like the feel of foam, I'm leaning towards the Saatva innerspring.  I'm not a fan of pillowtop but it's probably better quality and attached differently than the cheap ones I've seen.   Another reason to pause, is shipping is $270 to Iowa.

Meanwhile, I'm sleeping on a 20 year old Sealy twin innerspring that is still firm and bouncy.  I nearly fell off one night but I prefer it to the full size mattress in a bag I got from Walmart.  (it's a close call though)  It seems like the Walmart 13" Signature Club mattress is comparable to a mid-range Serta for 1/5 the price and it is good backup.

Anyone not like the Saatva's pillowtop?  I've yet to find a negative review.

Re: Need a topper for new Serta Innerspring
Reply #9 Sep 2, 2012 2:27 PM
Joined: Jul 13, 2012
Points: 31
If you are looking at a latex mattress may I suggest you take a look at the products offered by SleepEZ? In doing my research I have found review after review raving about their customer service and product. They will allow you to swap out a layer if it isn't right for you and also allow you to return it for a $99 flat fee. You can have different softnesses per side so you can customize the bed to you and your partners preferences. Also their latex is manufactured by Latex International.

 

I am in no way affiliated with SleepEZ, just done a ton of research on latex mattresses and have seen them time and again as one of the highest reviewed latex mattresses and the best price. Good luck on your search.

Recent Posts