Latex mattress is too hard
Oct 21, 2011 2:38 PM
Joined: Sep 30, 2011
Points: 60
New member here ... and I'm in a conundrum.

 

Perhaps 10 years ago I bought an Englander latex foam mattress.   It's a latex slab with thin egg-crate glued to each side, and a cover.   At some point I decided I didn't like the support - felt like it was giving me a backache - so I removed the egg crate on one side, and let that be the bottom side permanently.    Was pretty happy with that for some years, but had pondered maybe removing the egg crate from the top too.

Recently, girlfriend was diagnosed with dust-mite allergy, so I decided to go ahead and trash the cover and remove the top layer of eggcrate.   So I now just have a slab of latex, about 6" thick, with a mattress cover on top.   And it's too hard - I am a side sleeper, and it's pretty uncomfortable on my hips.   I like a firm mattress, but it's just too much.   The weird thing is, when you press on the latex with your hand, it feels kind of mushy.

So I wonder what to do.   I'm thinking maybe add back some sort of topper, of higher quality than the eggcrate, perhaps 2" of latex or memory foam bought from one of the mail-order places.   But I seek advice.   Please let me know if there's add'l info I should provide, and thanks.

This message was modified Oct 23, 2011 by RustyShackleford
Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #1 Oct 21, 2011 4:27 PM
Joined: May 3, 2008
Points: 827
How did you remove the layer if it was glued?

I too experience the latex seems soft when I push on it too, and it feels hard on the hip.  Maybe Budgy can explain that one.

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #2 Oct 21, 2011 6:16 PM
Joined: Sep 30, 2011
Points: 60
Leo3 wrote:

How did you remove the layer if it was glued?

 

I too experience the latex seems soft when I push on it too, and it feels hard on the hip.  Maybe Budgy can explain that one.


It wasn't glued very well.   Most of it just pulled away with only minimal resistance.   In a few places it took a litttle more persuasion and tore away maybe 1/4" of the latex.   Fortunately these places were near the corners.   It definitely takes a little patience, and I can imagine it might be a real problem if there were more glue.

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #3 Oct 22, 2011 3:08 PM
Joined: Oct 18, 2011
Points: 11
I'm no mattress expert, but when I tried putting memory foam on top of the latex, it actually made my bed feel harder! I think the foam distributed my weight too much, so the latex didn't give at all. Maybe some people had a different experience, but why not just put some softer latex on top? I've read a few places on this forum that you want as little as possible between you and the latex. Do you know what ILD your mattress is?
Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #4 Oct 23, 2011 2:16 PM
Joined: Sep 30, 2011
Points: 60
lefty2026 wrote:

I'm no mattress expert, but when I tried putting memory foam on top of the latex, it actually made my bed feel harder! I think the foam distributed my weight too much, so the latex didn't give at all. Maybe some people had a different experience, but why not just put some softer latex on top? I've read a few places on this forum that you want as little as possible between you and the latex. Do you know what ILD your mattress is?

Don't know the ILD; I guess I should research how to measure it.

Yeah, I don't like some of the stuff I' reading about memory-foam (too warm in hot weather, hard to move around).   Maybe I should look at a topper of something else, like a lower-ILD latex like you suggest.    I'm still confused by the fact that my existing latex (from my dis-assembled mattress) feels so mushy to the touch, but too hard when sleeping on it.

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #5 Oct 23, 2011 2:37 PM
Joined: Sep 30, 2011
Points: 60
Another factor is that I am prone to back pain from a mattress that isn't supportive enough.   It felt like my latex with the 1" or so of crappy PU eggcrate was causing back pain.   Which is one of the main reasons I removed it.   And now it's too hard.    Kinda the worst of both worlds.   I definitely find there ARE mattresses with firm enough support to prevent back pain and yet very comfortable for side sleeping - like in a beach house we rent a lot (I think it's just a high-quality innerspring mattress).

 

I'm rambling, but that's how confused I am - please help !!

P.S. I should add that I'm 5'10" and 170lb, and am a side sleeper.

P.P.S.  It seems like it'd be REALLY helpful if I could determine the ILD iof my current latex.   Can someone point me to a thread that tells how to do a DIY measurement ?   Is it as simple as cutting a 50 square-icnh piece of plywood and weighting it until it deflects a certain amount ?   It was from an Englander "Latex Plus" mattress bought in 1998.

This message was modified Oct 23, 2011 by RustyShackleford
Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #6 Oct 23, 2011 4:05 PM
Location: Yosemite area
Joined: Sep 10, 2008
Points: 249
Yeah, pushing foam with your hand doesn't tell you much.  I think that you'd want somewhere between one to two inches of a p/u foam to soften the latex.  Layering foams seems to be the best way to reach optimum feel for sleeping. 

Kait

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #7 Oct 23, 2011 6:16 PM
Joined: Sep 30, 2011
Points: 60
Kait wrote:

Yeah, pushing foam with your hand doesn't tell you much.  I think that you'd want somewhere between one to two inches of a p/u foam to soften the latex.  Layering foams seems to be the best way to reach optimum feel for sleeping. 

 

Kait


Thanks for weighing in, Kait.   If I don't mind spending a little more, do you think 1-2" of a low-ILD latex would be better than the p/u ?   If so, thoughts about Talalay vs Dupont or whatever ?

 

 

 

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #8 Oct 24, 2011 11:17 AM
Joined: Oct 18, 2011
Points: 11

My personal opinion would be to go with latex over p/u, because you were not happy with the p/u to begin with and the allergy resistance is important to you.  I would go to some stores though and try to find latex mattresses that you like, then you can see what ILD they are made from and try to match it with what you have and what you would want to buy, plus you can make sure that there is a latex bed out there you do like. 

You can read about talaway vs dunlop online.  Supposedly they have different feels, but talaway is more consistent.  Most people say dunlop is firmer than Talaway.  Talaway does come in softer ILDs than dunlop.

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #9 Oct 24, 2011 1:58 PM
Joined: Sep 30, 2011
Points: 60
lefty2026 wrote:


My personal opinion would be to go with latex over p/u, because you were not happy with the p/u to begin with and the allergy resistance is important to you.  I would go to some stores though and try to find latex mattresses that you like, then you can see what ILD they are made from and try to match it with what you have and what you would want to buy, plus you can make sure that there is a latex bed out there you do like. 

 

You can read about talaway vs dunlop online.  Supposedly they have different feels, but talaway is more consistent.  Most people say dunlop is firmer than Talaway.  Talaway does come in softer ILDs than dunlop.

I like the sound of the latex over p/u, but it seems a little silly to spend almost $600 (queen at FBM) when I already have a nice 6" slab of latex.

Last night, I laid my summer down comforter (maybe 1-2" of loft uncompressed) plus a fleece blanket over the latex, and I found it pretty comfortable.   I'm guessing that's probably equivalent to no more than 1" of a topper of some kind.   So maybe I just try 1" of a soft latex topper and I'll be happy.  Of course, if I'm right that I wasn't getting enough support when I still had the 1" eggcrate on my latex, I doubt if the same rig but with 1" latex would be much better in that regard.

If that's true, then I guess it's just saying that my 6" latex slab is simply too soft to serve as a base layer for me, and I DO need to start over as you suggest.

 

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #10 Oct 25, 2011 1:56 PM
Joined: Sep 30, 2011
Points: 60
I'm thinking the thing to do is to get a latex topper, probaby from FBM.   Leaning towards 2" ILD 20 (I'm a 170lb side sleeper) but welcome suggestions to the contrary.  If it doesn't do the job, then perhaps it can be the basis of a new creation using a firmer base.
Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #11 Oct 25, 2011 11:47 PM
Joined: Oct 25, 2011
Points: 3
Hi all, i've worked in the bedding manufacturing industry for 16yrs now. If you are purchasing a latex topper to create a plusher sleeping surface, make sure it is an ECO certified (100% natural rubber) latex topper. Generally 7.5cm thick will re-invigorate an existing mattress that is too firm, while a 5cm topper will adjust the feel slightly. The thicker option is best suited for individuals that side sleep, while the 5cm is suitable for "all-rounders" (ie, ppl that sleep in all posi's- side, back stomach, semi-stomach). Your existing latex block will last up to another 20yrs if it is 100% natural latex rubber (ECO certified), however beware- if your latex does not have an outer covering it will be prone to excessive UV exposure which will accelerate the oxidisation process (natural decomposition of the outer block- yellowing/flaking), at very least cover it with a fitted mattress protector (cotton or tencel) to minimise UV.

Adding a topper is probably the only way to spark some life back into that mattress. In regards to Visco-elastic foam toppers (memory foam/ tempur etc.), beware- they are infamous as the hottest sleeping surface material in the industry, as it is a heat-sensitive foam type that restricts when in contact with the bodies natural heat, allowing for the fine contouring & slow release of the foam structure- inturn, for this material to be effective it has to have no buffer (airlayer) such as a fibre pillowtop as this neutralises the effectiveness of memory foam, & due to it's tight polymer structure, cannot breathe nor ventilate the sleeping surface to dissapate bodyheat.

Good luck in searching out a topper, keep in mind- if it is latex, make sure it is both ECO certified & LGA tested latex, that way you will get a product that is 100% natural, extremely long lasting, pin-cored for maximised ventilation, anti-bacterial, anti-fungal, dustmite free........ preferably covered in a breathable material (cotton, bamboo/cotton, tencel, ingeo)....stay away from rayon, dacron & polyester (too hot!).

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #12 Oct 26, 2011 1:03 AM
Joined: Oct 25, 2011
Points: 3
re: Talalay or Dunlop.........Dunlop latex process utilises microwave techniques to cook the water content out of the polymerised latex sap creating a 100% natural latex rubber that retains the Hevea's natural properties of being anti-bacterial, anti-fungal, & dustmite free, it is also a much longer lasting material type. To make sure your mattress has had decent 3rd party testing, look for a LGA tested logo. LGA tests are a compression/durability test conducted on bedding materials (latex, foam, springs) to determine the longeveity of the material under regular duress. This LGA quality test & the ECO certification are the basic consumer tools you need to look out for when purchasing a 100% natural latex mattress. DO NOT simply take the salesmans word on it, very few manufacturers use 100% latex in their mattress construction, instead opting to reinforce the loft/thickness with inexpensive material types like Firm Foam base layering (P/U foam), & Soft Comfort layering with low grade plush P/U foam, instead of simply using firmer or softer latex layers.

Talalay techniques utilise catalyst chemicals to convert the polymer, leaving behind trace chemicals of the catalyst components. Also talalay will incorporate anywhere from 30%-100% synthetic latex foam which is a derivitive of the petro-chemical industry. It will also have  additives such as Ultra-fresh (organic tin compound) & Healthgard (sanitised treatment) to mimick the natural properties of natural latex.

It's a minefield out there!!!! Where brandnames mean nothing & retail cost mean even less when sourcing true quality materials. Certifications & testing are the only buyers tools worth trusting, that & thorough research.

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #13 Oct 26, 2011 3:23 AM
Joined: Mar 25, 2011
Points: 30
Rusty,

I'm in a similar situation as you, but my latex mattress is new from SleepEz. 8.5 inches thick. currently on the floor as we try to figure out what foundation to get. 

I've tried various configurations of the layers using soft/med/firm, more firm, more soft, etc layers. it doesnt seem to make a difference - my lower back hurts all the time and my right shoulder has developed a very bad constant pain since sleeping on this mattress. i sleep in multiple positions - back, sides, semi-stomach.... 

the frustating thing is I sleep fine on an inexpensive firm, older innerspring Simmons at my Mom's house. no back or shoulder pain from it. i feel frustrated for spending so much money and doing so much research to end up w/a mattress that isn't very comfortable for me...

I'm also confused on what foundation - i'm getting conflicting info -  eg. needs to be on a slatted base vs. needs a solid surface, not slatted. which is it?????

the quality wood slatted foundations are expensive. so if you buy one and then have to add plywood over the slats what is the point.

 

can anyone clear this up?

 

 

 

 

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #14 Oct 26, 2011 10:35 AM
Joined: Oct 18, 2011
Points: 11
RustyShackleford wrote:

 

I like the sound of the latex over p/u, but it seems a little silly to spend almost $600 (queen at FBM) when I already have a nice 6" slab of latex.

Last night, I laid my summer down comforter (maybe 1-2" of loft uncompressed) plus a fleece blanket over the latex, and I found it pretty comfortable.   I'm guessing that's probably equivalent to no more than 1" of a topper of some kind.   So maybe I just try 1" of a soft latex topper and I'll be happy.  Of course, if I'm right that I wasn't getting enough support when I still had the 1" eggcrate on my latex, I doubt if the same rig but with 1" latex would be much better in that regard.

If that's true, then I guess it's just saying that my 6" latex slab is simply too soft to serve as a base layer for me, and I DO need to start over as you suggest.

 



Sorry, I meant I would suggest getting a latex topper rather than a regular foam topper.  I think ordering the 1 in of 20 from FBM is probably a decent bet.  You could get 2 inches if you think you need it, but if you start with one inch, you can see if you want firmer or softer and look into buying another inch - or fold the latex in half to see how 2 inches of the same would feel. 

Egg crate foam is only for adding a soft feel, it's pretty much completely unsupportive.  Even soft latex will provide some support since it pushes back, so you might like it.   

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #15 Oct 26, 2011 2:23 PM
Joined: Sep 30, 2011
Points: 60
alopex wrote:

I'm in a similar situation as you, but my latex mattress is new from SleepEz. 8.5 inches thick. currently on the floor as we try to figure out what foundation to get. 

I've tried various configurations of the layers using soft/med/firm, more firm, more soft, etc layers. it doesnt seem to make a difference - my lower back hurts all the time and my right shoulder has developed a very bad constant pain since sleeping on this mattress. i sleep in multiple positions - back, sides, semi-stomach.... 

the frustating thing is I sleep fine on an inexpensive firm, older innerspring Simmons at my Mom's house. no back or shoulder pain from it. i feel frustrated for spending so much money and doing so much research to end up w/a mattress that isn't very comfortable for me...

I'm also confused on what foundation - i'm getting conflicting info -  eg. needs to be on a slatted base vs. needs a solid surface, not slatted. which is it?????

the quality wood slatted foundations are expensive. so if you buy one and then have to add plywood over the slats what is the point.

 

can anyone clear this up?

Hmm, sounds like you might need a zoned system, with a firmer topper under your butt and something soft for your shoulders.

And I too find the most comfortable mattress is at the beach house we've rented for several years - dunno if it's expensive or cheap.   I like the foam mattress in theory - it makes a heckuva lot more sense - but can't quite get it right.

As far as a foundation, solid surface is a strict no-no (as I understand it).   The mattress needs to breath out moisture underneath or you will be in for big trouble.   I made a base of plywood and drilled a bunch of holes in it - I hope I drilled enough, I think I did, since there doesn't seem to be noticeable moisture on the bottom of the mattress.  I think slats are fine too *IF* they are supported well enough to not sag at all.

Another thing which I've always sensed, and my girlfriend conformed in her reading about allergies.   Do NOT make up your bed, instead pull the covers back and let the thing dry out during the day.

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #16 Oct 26, 2011 2:26 PM
Joined: Sep 30, 2011
Points: 60
lefty2026 wrote:

 



Sorry, I meant I would suggest getting a latex topper rather than a regular foam topper.  I think ordering the 1 in of 20 from FBM is probably a decent bet.  You could get 2 inches if you think you need it, but if you start with one inch, you can see if you want firmer or softer and look into buying another inch - or fold the latex in half to see how 2 inches of the same would feel. 

Egg crate foam is only for adding a soft feel, it's pretty much completely unsupportive.  Even soft latex will provide some support since it pushes back, so you might like it.   


Wow, jsut 1" to start with, huh ?   And I was trying to decide between 2" and 3".  But your plan makes sense - if it's too thin, maybe add an inch of the 32 under the 20.

Thanks for the heads-up on certifications, Lukey.   Anyone know if FBM's stuff meets these ?

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #17 Oct 26, 2011 8:10 PM
Joined: Oct 25, 2011
Points: 3
G'day Rusty.......just call them & ask about the certifications.

The reason some mattresses (Latex or otherwise) require a firm flat base (not slatted) is simply due to the base layering used in the mattress, ie- the foam layer used in construction as a support layer (& a great way to add thickness to a mattress without adding any latex) or in the case of "flippable" mattresses it's to do with the soft foam "comfort layers" that has been used. Some cheap P/U foam types cannot handle the dipping between each slat & will get permanent rutts from the foam collapsing under duress. It is extremely common for bedding manufacturers to use cost saving methods during production such as limiting the amount of actual latex in the mattress, & bolstering the overall thickness with cheap nasty P/U foam that is heavily treated with fat soluble chemicals such as flame retarder, dyes, masking perfumes, & VOC's that can seriously affect chemically sensitive souls. P/U foams also only have a third of the longevity that natural latex will give you.

Mattresses that can handle slatting, generally will have latex base layers (support layers on single sided no-flip mattresses) or durable comfort layers made from latex rubber (flippable mattress types) so inturn can handle the dipping between each slat that occurs. Due to the fact that natural latex rubber does not rely on displacement of air when compressed like foam does, so it will always have close to 100% return after compression (like a LGA test procedure), whereas for foam to have 100% return of loft, it will rely on drawing back air into the foam structure. The less the air can draw back into the foam, the flatter more unsupportive the foam will get. This will also change the overall density of the support or comfort layer, simply put- foam is cheap & sucks.

When you purchase a latex mattress, use this simple check-list of questions to ask the retailer or (prefferably) manufacturer:

*ECO certified latex (100% natural)??? why? natural latex is anti-bacterial, anti-fungal, dustmite free, biodegradeable, renewable, untreated & extremely long lasting.

*LGA tested (quality/duability tested)??? why? to ensure that your mattress will have the same feel 5years down the track, & for warranty assurances.

*Is the pillowtop 100% natural fibre (wool, alpaca, tencel, ingeo)??, or is it 100% synthetic (polyester, dacron, rayon blended) or a blended fibre (wool/poly, wool/dacron etc)??? Why? natural fibres will breathe under your skin creating an airflow layer that disperses bodyheat build-up & promotes out-venting of airflow caused by the pincoring of the latex (venting system/mold). Also, synthetic materials do not absorb any moisture, giving you a clammy, hot sleeping surface.

*Is the support structure 100% latex layering (combination of densities)?, or is it combined with foam layering (base layer, comfort layer, central support layer)???? Why? P/U foam layers reduce internal airflow, last a quarter to a third of the life of natural latex. Are a cost cutting method used during production to maximise profit margins within products. Are heavily treated. Unrenewable.

*Is the outer fabric or quilting natural, or synthetic fabric (polyester)??? Why? heat, simply heat......synthetic fabrics reduce airflow & are simply HOT.

Rusty, I would look for a topper that is set to a 5 (prefferable) or 7 posture zone setting that will target a softer zone for your shoulders, whilst giving you a firmer support zone for your hips & lower back. Avoid any mono-zone posture zoning as they are for beanpole bodytypes, not really sidesleepers. The thicker the topper, the better. 3 inch (7.5cm) is generally the go, set in a plush medium density to reduce that counter-pressure on the shoulder.

Good luck mate.

LukeyDC- cobber from Oz.

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #18 Oct 27, 2011 12:26 AM
Joined: Sep 30, 2011
Points: 60
 


Thanks for all the info Lukey.   Would you please check out my other thread on DIY measurement of IDL and comment on it ?

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #19 Oct 27, 2011 5:16 AM
Joined: May 22, 2010
Points: 3
I bought the 3" soft from FBM/FF and love it.  I was worried about all the complaints about smell and so forth, but I let it air out according to the directions, and bought the terry cloth cover and have been very happy with it.  The hardest part was getting it into the house (I used my feet and thus leg strength to roll it in and then tumbled it up onto a spare bed where I lay it out).  I definitely needed help to get it on the bed -- myself and two other women. 

But after 18 months I find that the underbed is still too hard, so am looking for a softer latex underneath... looking at the medium talalay.  Any thoughts?

 

sleep deprived

Re: Latex mattress is too hard
Reply #20 Nov 13, 2011 3:37 PM
Joined: Sep 30, 2011
Points: 60
lefty2026 wrote:

 



Sorry, I meant I would suggest getting a latex topper rather than a regular foam topper.  I think ordering the 1 in of 20 from FBM is probably a decent bet.  You could get 2 inches if you think you need it, but if you start with one inch, you can see if you want firmer or softer and look into buying another inch - or fold the latex in half to see how 2 inches of the same would feel. 

Egg crate foam is only for adding a soft feel, it's pretty much completely unsupportive.  Even soft latex will provide some support since it pushes back, so you might like it.   


Ok, I ordered the 1" of 20ILD latex from FBM.   It is an improvement, but I still get pressure points on the sides of my hips when side-sleeping (which is most of the time).   So I'm wondering, what next ?   I guess I'll fold the 1" piece in half and see how that feels.

Recent Posts